For an injured Local 3 electrician, traditional Workers' Comp doesn't exist. The fund runs its own comp claim system, and MagnaComp is the door to its doctors.
The fund's program handles your comp claim: the doctors, the checks, the disputes. But that's all it does.
A fall, a falling object, or a site safety failure can support a separate case against the owner or general contractor. The MagnaComp program will not help you collect the money you and your family might be owed.
Recent Results
$26,500,000
For an operating engineer seriously injured in a car wreck
$24,750,000
For a union laborer who suffered a double leg amputation
$9,500,000
for an elevator apprentice struck by the cab
Free Consultation
No Obligations
The Program Behind the Phone Number
Most New York comp claims run through the Workers' Compensation Board. Yours does not. It runs through the Electrical Employers Self Insurance Safety Plan, or E.E.S.I.S.P. The Joint Industry Board of the Electrical Industry built it for IBEW Local 3 members. The fund's own page says the Board granted E.E.S.I.S.P. authority in 1996 to operate an alternative dispute resolution program for claims filed after that date. The fund calls itself "the largest entity in the state which operates an ADR program." Take that as their description of their own creation.
The legal footing is WCL § 25(2-c). That statute lets a collective bargaining agreement in covered construction trades set up its own claim process.
MagnaComp is none of the familiar players. Not the Board. Not the union hall. Not your lawyer. It is the vendor routing medical care inside the fund's program. A Broadspire letter means something different, a project insurance wrap, and that article covers it. Figure out which program owns your claim before anything else.
What Happens When You Dial
MagnaComp refers you to doctors in its network. The fund's FAQ puts the rule bluntly: "you must use a doctor in the MagnaComp network or payment of bills will be denied." Read that twice. New York's general rule lets an injured worker choose his own treating doctor. Inside this program, the network chooses. This companion article explains the usual free-choice rule, and an ADR network is one of its exceptions.
On a job site, the emergency exception matters most. MagnaCare FAQ says: "If you require immediate or emergency treatment following an injury, you may go to any hospital or walk-in clinic. If additional treatment is required, you must contact MagnaComp for a referral to an in-network provider." So the emergency room is always allowed. Get treated first. Then make the referral call before follow-up care begins. Denied bills come from skipping that call. The number sits on your fund's E.E.S.I.S.P. page.
The network rule has limits of its own. It routes care. It does not report the injury for you, and it does not build your medical proof. Tell the network doctor the full story: how it happened, every body part, every symptom you kept working through. Those visit notes become the basis of your claim.
Twelve to Fourteen Days, and a Statutory Floor
Per the fund's FAQ, a correctly filed claim should produce a first check roughly 12 to 14 days after your first full day out of work. That timing lines up with New York comp generally. This article covers what sets the amount.
The law also builds a floor. WCL § 25(2-c) forbids the agreement from diminishing your statutory benefits. The process can change. The dollar minimums cannot. A late or light check is not something to absorb quietly. It is a dispute, and this program sends disputes down an unusual path.
Disputes Skip the Board Entirely
An ordinary claim puts disputes before a Board judge, with review by a Board panel. This program does neither. Under 12 NYCRR 314.3, unresolved claims go to arbitration under the rules the agreement sets. Any appeal goes straight to the Appellate Division, Third Department, within 30 days of notice that the arbitrator's award was filed. The regulation states it flatly: "There shall be no intermediate review by the Workers' Compensation Board."
Court review is narrow. Two published decisions examined electrical industry ADR awards under the limited arbitration standard: Matter of Peterec-Tolino v Commercial Elec. Contrs. and Matter of Diaz v Kleinknecht Elec. In both, the program's decision held up.
Take the practical lesson. The arbitration hearing is your real day in court on the comp claim. The record you bring is the record you finish with. Getting serious only after a bad award is getting serious too late.
The Second Claim, Untouched
Everything above governs one claim only: workers' compensation. Comp pays medical bills and a share of lost wages. It pays nothing for pain. It pays nothing for the career an injury ends. When a fuller recovery exists, it comes from a different case entirely.
Labor Law § 240 and § 241 place safety duties on owners and general contractors. A ladder or scaffold fall, a dropped pipe or fitting, a violation of the specific construction safety rules: each can support a lawsuit against the owner or GC. That suit names neither your employer nor Local 3. The ADR program has no jurisdiction over it. Using MagnaComp's network waives nothing. No arbitrator ever hears it. Here is how a case beyond comp works, and here is what it looks like for electricians specifically.
This is the piece that gets lost. A member follows the packet perfectly and never hears that the owner's liability was its own question, with its own three-year clock. Nobody hid it. The program simply was never built to raise it.
Counsel, on Both Tracks
Schwartzapfel Holbrook has handled many cases with Local 3's ADR program. We are here to help you navigate the system and make sure you are getting fully payed on the MagnaComp end.
At the same time, we investigate whether you have a case against someone else on the job site. Since you can't sue your employer in New York, we look for any other insurance policies available that you can collect against.
Working with your body is how you provide for your family, and if you can no longer do it the way you once did, we want to make sure you are protected financially for life. That is what "third-party" cases are really about; getting the money and benefits you would have earned over your career had you not been injured.
